Spoiler data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a4154/a415414f3b25bada2d6a9a6e2e7202cfa6ae75f0" alt=">"
It's rather easy once you figure it out. "Children of the Sea" means anything from the ocean. Shells, fish, clams, starfish. That stuff. As long as it adds up to a total of 25 it will work. Drop them on the rock. You get em underwater around the island. Hope that helps!